One of my most prized possessions is the Ohio State vs. Miami National Championship game tape. I've seen it so many times I probably have Keith Jackson's commentary memorized. But I was watching it again a couple nights ago and got to thinking. That 2002 squad was special, but when you got right down to it, they weren't incredibly talented. And the 2006 team that reached the national title game was supremely talented. The 2007 Buckeyes are in the cat-bird seat right now, as well. Which is the best Buckeye team of the Jim Tressel era?
Well, as only a sports information director would do, here is a three-way breakdown. One part objective (statistics) the other part subjective (how I feel). It was originally going to be one blog, but it's ridiculously long. And after three days of work, I've decided it to be a three-day post: the offense on Thursday, defense and special teams on Friday and a conclusion Saturday morning before kickoff.
So why waste any more time. Let the debate begin!
Team stat comparison Offense Passing2002 - 2,425 yards passing, 14 TD, 7 INT, 60 percent completion, 8.5 yd/A
2006 - 2,791 yards, 31 TD, 6 INT, 65 percent completion, 8.2 yd/A
2007 - 1,985 yards, 22 TD, 8 INT, 66.2 percent completion, 8.3 yd/A
On pace for - 2,867, 31 TD, 11.5 INT
Rushing2002 - 2,710 yards rushing, 617 attempts, 4.39 yards per carry, 193.6 per game, 31 TD
2006 - 2,208 yards, 480 attempts, 4.6 yards per carry, 169.8 per game, 25 TD
2007 - 1,788 yards, 392 attempts, 4.6 yards per carry, 198.7 per game, 12 TD
On pace for - 2,583 yards, 566 attempts, 17 TD
Points per game/average margin of victory2002 - 29.28 (410 total)/16.21
2006 - 34.6 (450 total)/21.8
2007 - 34.6 (311 total)/25.7
On pace for 450 points/25.7
Wins over ranked opponents2002 - 4 (Washington State, Penn State, Michigan, Miami)
2006 - 4 (Texas, Penn State, Iowa, Michigan)
2007 - 1 (Penn State)
Defense 2002 - 183 points allowed (13.07 per game) ranked 3nd in nation in rush defense (77.7), 95th in pass defense (243.1).
2006 - 19 TD allowed, 38 sacks, 202 first downs allowed, 12.8 points allowed, 7.82 through first 11 games
2007 - 80 points allowed, 5 TD allowed, 8.9 points per game allowed, 27 sacks (on pace for 39)
All-Americans2002 - 4 (Mike Doss, Andy Groom, Mike Nugent, Matt Wilhelm)
2006 - 2, Troy Smith, James Laurinaitis
2007 - INC - You would almost have to assume that Laurinaitis is a shoe-in for his second selection and my gut tells me that Gholstin has an outside shot. Malcolm Jenkins looks like an All-American, too. Offensively, Chris Wells and Brian Robiskie could have the stats if they finish strong, but I doubt it. Kirk Barton at tackle is also a candidate.
Intangibles2002 - This team had every intangible you could imagine. It won seven games of seven points or less with miracle offensive plays and defensive turnovers. Sometimes it cannot be explained on paper. The biggest key was likely its seniors that had been through the trying to times of a coaching change and two down seasons (by Ohio State standards).
2006 - Flat out more talented than any one else they played. The Buckeyes of ’06 got by on its superior speed and athleticism until the title game. The Troy Smith group was part of Tressel’s first full recruiting class and Ginn obviously delivered on the hype he had coming out of high school. The impressive numbers of this team was its 49 percent third-down conversion rate and 21 interceptions compared to just six thrown. The team did not commit turnovers. If this team lacked anything, it was likely the intangibles, as there was a great deal of rumbling after the title game that leadership failed, coaching failed and overall, the team got complacent because of its sheer regular season dominance.
2007 - So far, the Buckeyes of 2007 have not played a close game, but there is a sense that the team is playing with a chip on its shoulder and looking to gain the respect it lost against Florida. By most accounts, the defense and special teams have rung up more big hits early this year than all of last. Also, Tressel’s penchant for conservative play calling has been disregarded despite the having a first-year starter at quarterback. The defense is averaging an absurd three sacks per game and an interception per game.
Quarterback2002- Craig Krenzel - 148-249, 59.4%, 2,110 yards, 12 TD, 7 INT, 140.9 rating
Breakdown: Any one who watched a game in 2002 knew that Krenzel was a molecular genetics major (UGH!). That was actually a problem. His unwillingness to make a mistake inhibited the offense. His completion percentage and lack of touchdowns speak for themselves (he completed 7-of-21 passes in the title game). He was reticent to actually throw the ball most of the time and had an incredibly weak arm. What he lacked it talent, he TRIED to make up for in toughness. The kid took some wicked hits against Miami and kept playing (81 rushing yards). I have no idea how he did it. He also gets credit for making some huge throws and runs in tight situations. But one must wonder, if he had been a better quarterback for three quarters, would there be any need for those clutch plays in the fourth?
2006 - Troy Smith - 203-311, 65.3%, ,2542 yards, 30 TD, 6 INT, 161.91 rating
Breakdown: The great thing to me about Troy wasn’t his playmaking, it was that he hardly ever made mistakes. 30 TD’s to six picks is a phenomenal ratio. Sure, he had great playmakers around him (unlike Krenzel) but his leadership was also something cannot be overlooked. The team clearly rallied around him. The only issue was that the team probably relied on him too much at times. To his credit, he didn’t have a down game until his last one. Let’s not forget, he was 3-0 against that team from up north.
2007 - Todd Boeckman - 139-209, 66.5%, 21 TD, 8 INT, 164.3 rating (on pace for 201-302, 66.5%, 30 TD, 12 INT)
Breakdown: People started comparing Boeckman to Krenzel even before he threw a pass. But let me tell you, Boeckman is light years ahead of Krenzel at his best. While he has made a few mistakes (almost an interception per game), they haven’t been costly mistakes. And at least he’s letting it fly with all those weapons he has. A worse crime would be not trying to get the ball to the playmakers. Believe it or not, he’s more accurate than Troy Smith by a percentage point and could possibly finish the season with the highest single season touchdown total in school history. My only concern at quarterback is depth. But as long as Boeckman stays healthy, Tressel will have him more than prepared for the big games.
Running Back2002 - Maurice Clarett - 221 carries, 1,237 yards, 5.6 avg., 16 TD
Maurice Hall - 78 carries, 370 yards, 4 TD
Lydell Ross - 167 carries, 619 yards, 3.7 avg, 6 TD
Breakdown: Pop a tape from 2002 and fall in love with Clarett all over again. We won’t discuss what became of Clarett, just what he was for one season. Injury prone, yes. But he had quick feet (Wisconsin game), strength to break tackles (Washington State) and breakaway speed (Texas Tech). He was the complete package and I still maintain that OSU would have won the national title in 2003 had he been a part of the team. Hall and Ross comprised the worst backup running backs in the last 20 years at Ohio State. Ross declined every year after his freshman season (although he played well in spot against Miami), and Hall ran in a straight line no matter who was in front him (he did score the game-winner against Michigan). On any other team, those two backs would have never sniffed the field.
2006 - Antonio Pittman - 242 carries, 1,275 yards, 5.1 avg., 14 TD
Beanie Wells - 104 carries, 587 yards, 5.5 avg., 7 TD
Breakdown: This was undoubtedly the best running back combo we’d seen at OSU since possibly Raymont Harris/Eddie George/Butler Bynote back in 1993. I loved Pittman for his deceptive speed and his sneaky strength. He finished runs like a big back despite the fact he was tiny. Beanie was a great change up with his power. However, he had some serious ball control issues during this season. They both had the ability to move the chains and to break off big runs (Michigan).
2007 - Beanie Wells - 174 carries, 996 yards, 5.7 avg., 7 TD, 110.7 per game
(on pace for 251 carries, 1,431 yards, 10 TD)
Mo Wells - 93 carries, 325 yards, 3.5 avg., 2 TD, 36.1 (134, 469 yards, 3 TD)
Brandon Saine - 49 carries, 265 yards, 5.1 avg., 2 TD, 35.6 (71, 383 yards, 3 TD)
Breakdown: At several times this year, I’ve actually proclaimed Beanie as the second coming of Eddie George. He finishes runs like 27 used to, has a powerful stiff arm and nimble feet for a 230-pounder. He is the complete package and is on pace to rush for the eighth best single-season total in school history. However, I’m not a fan of Wells. He is a Maurice Hall clone to me and their first names aren’t the only thing they have in common. For a guy that is supposedly a burner, his 3.5 yards per carry and long run of 26 aren’t impressive. Saine, however, is going to be special. He’s not nearly as physical as Beanie but has more speed. I love how Tressel has gotten him involved in the passing game, as well. Even though I’m not a fan of Wells, this three-back stable is tough to beat.
Fullback2002 - Brandon Joe - 1 carry, 1 yard
Breakdown: Joe was the classic Ohio State fullback. Bust your head and get no love for it. He was a good one, though. A tidbit of info that I bet you didn’t know--he was the leading rusher against Michigan in 2003 (another example of how horrible Ross and Hall were at tailback).
2006 - Stan White - 8 catches, 57 yards
Breakdown: Stan came in with Clarett, Smith and Zwick and was a highly touted linebacker prospect. He was switched to offense when AJ Hawk, Bobby Carpenter and the gang proved too talented. He was adequate. Didn’t run the ball once the entire season but did show reliable hands.
2007 - Dionte Johnson - 1 carry, -1 yard
Breakdown: Just like at running back, the 2007 Buckeyes use three fullbacks, Pepper, Jr., (Dionte) Trevor Robinson and Tyler “Tank” Whaley. All three are superior run blockers and ever since his freshman season, I’ve been a big fan of Dionte. There’s not a lot of love for the Buckeye fullbacks but Dionte delivers a blow. I guess there’s no chance of fatigue with three guys sharing the head-busting duties.
Wide Receiver2002 - Michael Jenkins - 61 rec, 1,076 yards, 17.6 avg, 6 TD
Chris Gamble - 31 rec, 499 yards, 16.1 avg, 0 TD
Chris Vance - 13 rec, 178 yards, 13.7 avg, 3 TD
Breakdown: Jenkins was a go-to guy and had little help on the opposite side. As bad as he has been in Atlanta, he was that good at Ohio State. Holy Buckeye, 4th and 14, and the Illinois overtime win were because of Michael. Great hands and the only really reliable receiver on the team. Gamble could have been a super wide receiver, but was forced to play defense because of the weakness at corner. I always loved Chris Vance. He had great hands, but for some reason did not play much. Tressel rarely ran three-wide sets in 2002 and Vance’s numbers show it. As a whole, Jenkins was the best of a thin and rather unspectacular group and that lack of depth really hurt the offenses ability to spread the field.
2006 - Ted Ginn - 59 rec, 781 yards, 13.2 avg., 9 TD
Anthony Gonzalez - 51 rec, 734 yards, 14.4 avg., 8 TD
Brian Robiskie - 29 rec., 383 yards, 13.2 avg., 5 TD
Breakdown: What a talented group of wide receivers. At no time in Ohio State history had two receivers been drafted in the first round of the NFL draft in the same year. Neither Gonzo or Ginn had numbers that would make your eyes pop out, but the balance was what made them deadly. Don’t discount Robo, Roy Hall, who had a huge game against Michigan (but broke Ginn’s foot in the bowl), and Hartline, either. Robiskie made some key receptions (Michigan). No one could cover Ginn, and his lower yard-per-catch average was because of the offense’s design. Both guys could stretch the field and take a screen pass for 60 yards. Gonzo was also a third-down assassin. Remember his run after catch against Iowa? Ridiculous.
2007 - Brian Hartline - 34 rec, 429 yards, 12.6 avg, 5 TD (on pace for 50 rec, 620 yards, 7 TD
Brian Robiskie - 41 rec, 787 yards, 19.2 avg, 8 TD (60 rec, 1,137 yards, 12 TD
Ray Small - 15 rec, 216 yards, 14.4 avg, 2 TD (22 rec, 312 yards, 3 TD)
Breakdown: While the receptions were spread around in 2006, we are seemingly back to a two-man show in 2007. We are still waiting for Small to turn into Teddy Ginn, III, but he’s been hampered by injury. He’s shown flashes, though. I didn’t really doubt that Robo and Hartline could shoulder the load, but I had no idea they would be this productive. I believe there have only been four 1,000-yard seasons by an OSU wide receiver and Robo could do it this year. If he finished with 11 TD’s, he‘d join the likes of Santonio Holmes, Joey Galloway and Chris Carter for the fourth-best single season total. That‘s elite company. He wins jump balls and is maybe even more polished as a receiver than Gonzo (thank you, Terry Robiskie). Hartline is steady and has shown an ability to run after the catch. He’s the perfect No. 2. The freshmen looked good early but there roles have been limited in Big Ten play.
Tight End 2002 - Ben Hartsock - 17 rec, 137 yards, 8.1 avg, 2 TD
Breakdown: Ben was rarely involved in the passing game but finished as the team’s No. 3 receiver, which shows how weak that passing game really was. He had nice hands but zero speed and was really a glorified tackle.
2006 - Rory Nicol - 13 rec., 151 yards, 11.6, 3 TD
Breakdown: The Ohio State tight end never plays much of a role. He was a better than average receiver but less than average blocker.
2007 - Rory Nicol - 14 rec, 82 yards
Jake Ballard - 9 rec, 114 yards, 2 TD
Breakdown: One of the things I love about the 2007 teamis how involved the tight ends are in the offense. Ballard, the No. 2 option, is close to matching Hartsock’s full season total already. Both guys are improved blockers, and Ballard is really underrated as a pass catcher.
Offensive Line2002 - Shane Olivea, Bryce Bishop, Alex Stepanovich, Adrien Clarke, Ivan Douglas
Breakdown: Olivea and Stepanovich have went to be starters at one point in the NFL, but as a unit, this offensive line was fairly horrendous. I haven’t the slightest idea how a team with such a line won 14 games. Part of the reason Krenzel had over 300 rushing yards in 2002 was because he ran a ridiculous amount of draw plays. Why? The line couldn’t pass protect. Maybe I’m being a little hard on this unit. Clarett had a great year. But look at the drop-off in production when Clarett wasn’t playing.
2006 - Alex Boone, Steve Rehring, Doug Datish, TJ Downing, Kirk Barton
Breakdown: This was still a pretty young group during this season and the stats show that they run blocked pretty effectively. I was never as impressed with Boone and Barton as TV analysts and Troy really bailed them out…a lot. The unit’s deficiencies were never more noticeable than in the championship game.
2007 - Alex Boone, Steve Rehring, Jim Cordle, Ben Person, Kirk Barton
Breakdown: It shouldn’t be surprising that Boone, Rehring and Barton (all starters in 2006) are improved. But this line has been flat out dominant. Boeckman has been sacked 10 times this year but against Penn State, the nation’s top pass rushing team, they surrendered only one sack and it didn’t come until the fourth. Early in the season against the likes of Youngstown and Akron, the line was pretty passive in their run blocking but I’ve been impressed lately.
Let me know what you think. The defense is tomorrow! Go Bucks!